Are MRIs of Disc Herniations Useful?

Are MRIs of Disc Herniations Useful?

This question is becoming more and more controversial for neck and low back pain. For the past few decades, healthcare has largely based its treatment options for disc herniations on image findings (X-ray, MRI, CT Scans). With these advanced tools, one would think positive outcomes with disc herniations would be significantly higher; however, different types of clinicians come to different conclusions when using different diagnostic and clinical tests. (1,2) This creates an approach based on a doctor’s theory of pain rather than a comprehensive, evidence-based approach.

Due to the lack of better outcomes (long-term pain reduction, quality of life, decreased health costs, self-efficacy, and independence) with using these tools, as well as the different interpretations of these tools we need to rethink their usefulness. (3) 

Does a Picture say a thousand words?

Let’s say you want to buy a new Chevy Tahoe. Would you buy the Tahoe based on a picture alone? A smart person would say no. There are many things to consider when buying a new vehicle. For starters, you would make sure there is an engine under the hood. Other things to consider: the interior, mileage, how well it runs on the highway, etc. The point is, you would make your decision based on several factors, not just a picture; a picture does not say a thousand words. 

Imaging, typically MRI, of the spine for disc herniations (aka slipped disc, bulges) should not be the sole, or most important factor, in deciding a course of action for treatment. The process on deciding what to do, and the relevance, for a disc herniation should be multi-factorial just as it is when purchasing a new vehicle.

Bulging Discs in Non-Painful People

Ron Donelson, former vice president of the American Back Society, stated “the only time it really matters where the pain is coming from is if some invasive treatment, like an injection or surgery, is being contemplated. (4) So, are disc findings on images useful? The answer is relatively no unless you are deciding on an injection or surgery and then you better make sure that the source of pain is discogenic and have exhausted other less invasive options first. You can always become more invasive (aggressive), but you cannot always undo invasive care. 

Research is constantly pointing out alterations (bulging, protrusion, extrusion, deterioration) with discs in non-painful individuals. In Quiroz-Moreno and college’s research, 55% of non-painful (5) individuals had these type of disc alterations. With more research supporting Quiroz-Moreno and college’s findings and the lack of productive outcomes we need to re-think the usefulness of disc herniation seen with imaging in terms of pain, outcomes, and interventions.

Resources:

1. Cushnaghan J, Cooper C, Dieppe P, Kirwan J, McAlindon T, McCrae F. Clinical assessment of osteoarthritis of the knee. Ann Rheum Dis. 1990;49:768-770.

2. Liesdek C, Van der Windt D, Koes B, Bouter L. Soft-tissue disorders of the shoulder: A study of inter-observer agreement between general practitioners and physiotherapists and an overview of physiotherapeutic treatment. Physiotherapy. 1997; 83: 12-17. 

3. Wnuk NM, et al. Magnetic resonance imaging of the lumbar spine: determining clinical impact and potential harm from overuse. Spine J. 2018 Apr. 18

4. Donelson R. Rapidly Reversible Low Back Pain. Hanover, NH: SelfCare First; 2007. pg. 133

5. Quiroz-Moreno R, Lezama-Suarez G, Gomez-Jimenez C., Disc alteration of lumbar spine on magnetic resonance images in asymptomatic workers. Rev Med Inst Mex Seguro Soc. 2008 Mar-Apr; 46(2): 185-90.

 

Have a Question?

Do you have a question about chiropractic care, fitness or nutrition?  We would love to hear from you, and we might even turn your question into our next blog post!

Ask a Question

Blog Topics

Rolling Patterns chiropractic Performance #localbusiness crossfit Lumbar Roll FAQ chiropractor adjustment Yoga Equipment Inner Thigh Body Awareness chiropractors Sitting Help weekend Strain crawling HamstringStrain inflammation Myths Healing motorpatterns Self Help DNS Headaches movement screen Latissimus Dorsi Rehabilitation Pectoralis Muscles physical therapy rollingpatterns Rhomboid Muscles Myofascial Release orthotics Low Back Pain esports DryNeedling Pain Management Fitness Shoes 2018 squats rehabilitation Nerve Pain Movement #Wichita dairy free sara skiles allergies Shoulder mechanics lifting #somethingsbrewingict WestWichita Heel Pain home stretches Tension pain management healthcare knee joint BeginningExercise Mechanics tummytime muscletherapy disc herniation Company Announcements ShoeShopping Grand Opening Acupuncture RunningShoes bodyawareness knee function patriotic community 5K Massage Healthcare ChiropracticOffice Plateau #HipPain running Dry Needling #freemuscletherapy Sprinting Adjustment Foam Rolling Foot Pain ICT doula plantar fasciitis stress Home Stretches Sitting Posture foot pain conditioning WestWichitaChiropractor Toe elbow pain Soft Tissue Therapy Conditioning GoTime Shoulder Pain Fitness Class #FootPain ChiropracticPhysician test Physical Therapy Functional Core Cupping Therapy postpartum squat Core Strength SportsChiropractor Accupuncture Orthotics Health sports Inflammation PlantarFasciitis Gym WSU Disc Herniation BackPain #RunningPain awareness #wholefoods #1millioncupsict development childbearing knee health #deepsquat Education guest blog tag2 Conservative Care Neurology GroupTraining knee pain Taping toe functionality FootExercise Squats FoamRollingFriday gaming #bellybreathing Handout Exercise myths functional chiropractor entrepreneur Chiropractic Feet #growingwichita #Running health Wet Needling Limitation Glute Muscles parenting Top 5 Pain #hipstrength Mobility Drill Information Membership Plan Lifting pregnancy foot complaint Hip Flexors WichitaChiropractor Elbow Pain Cost seminar wichita Treatment Options Compression Sleeves treatment options Mid-Back Pain mental health Mobility Payment 1MillionCups performance Wichita #races kansas rhomboid muscles Breathing race bodyweight Recovery Insurance Squat membership plan #KneePain Crossfit sport injuries ICTrunning MRI Running Adductors culture #localfarmers stability

Subscribe to Our Blog

Move HEALTHY.               Feel HEALTHY.              Live HEALTHY.